Jennifer Lopez wore nude platform sandals from Elie Saab with a floral dress in Los Angeles. Shop eight heeled sandals from Amazon, starting at $39.

She’s worn the style with jeans, summer dresses, and even on the red carpet.

I know something’s good when a star who can afford to never wear the same thing twice chooses to do so anyway. For Katie Holmes, that item is a Mansur Gavriel tote bag. Kylie Jenner repeatedly reaches for a pair of under-$100 Levi’s jeans, while Jennifer Lawrence is a shoe-loyalist, almost always wearing a pair of Adidas Sambas or mesh ballet flats. And I recently discovered Jennifer Lopez is also a little bit of a fashion-repeater—and for good reason.

This week, the actress was once again spotted in those nude, platform sandals from Elie Saab that she just rocked on the Atlas red carpet—but this wasn’t her first time re-wearing the shoes. This year alone she’s worn them six times, pairing them with wide-leg trousers, classic jeans, summer dresses, and high-fashion capes. I mean, the sky-high shoes look so good with everything—they elevate wardrobe basics and complement her dressiest pieces—that I, too, would wear them over and over again. TBH, I now want to, so I found eight lookalikes for her go-to heeled sandals at Amazon, starting at $39. 

Shop Jennifer Lopez’s Go-To Heeled Sandal

Rsxses Suede Platform Heeled Sandal, $39 Dream Pairs Platform Sandal, $40 Jeossy 8801 Wedge Sandal, $40 Cushionaire Sisi Heeled Sandal, $40 Clarks Giselle Dove Sandal, $45–$65 (Originally $95) The Drop Listilla Espadrille Wedge Sandal, $50 Dr. Scholl’s Felicity Too Block-Heel Sandal, $57 with coupon (Originally $90) Naturalizer Lilly Ankle-Strap Platform Sandal, $61 (Originally $110)

Dream Pairs Platform Sandal

Buy on Amazon $40

This $40 pair of platform sandals from Dream Pairs gets you pretty close to Lopez’s style with its tall platform, thick front straps, and a nude finish. It also features a chunky cork heel, which shoppers say is shockingly lightweight. The style is “not heavy…so they won’t tire your feet out,” said one shopper, adding that in addition to the weight, the platform makes them a must-have. “The shape of the heel makes it seem like you’re walking in a much lower heel or no heel” at all, they wrote. And per someone else, they “don’t even feel like [you’re] wearing heels…more like you’re walking in flats with how [well] they support your feet.”

Clarks Giselle Dove Sandal

Buy on Amazon $95 $46

The Giselle Dove sandals from Clarks are another great lookalike for Lopez’s heeled sandal, even including that same supportive ankle strap—and shoppers can’t stop raving about how good they feel and look. “It is not only comfortable, it looks good and does not feel unstable,” wrote someone who had “sworn off heels” before this pair. According to a shopper who “lives…in sneakers,” these heeled sandals felt like “winning…the shoe lottery.” They’re stylish, don’t cause foot pain, and fit perfectly, they gushed, while another fan who deemed them a compliment-magnet said that they’re “the most comfortable dress shoes [they] have ever worn.”

Dr. Scholl's Felicity Too Block-Heel Sandal

Buy on Amazon $90 $57

While Lopez’s sandals featured super-wide upper straps, Dr. Scholl’s on-sale Felicity Too sandals are perfect for those who like her style but prefer something a little thinner. This heeled sandal includes two belted straps, one just below the toes and the other wrapped around the ankle for extra stability. A number of customers say they “can walk in them for several hours” thanks to the cushioned insoles, with one person even comparing the comfort to “walking on a pillow.” And like Lopez’s shoes, they look good with everything, with one shopper even writing that they often wear theirs with classic jeans.

Lopez wears neutral platform sandals with pretty much everything, and I’m following her lead. Below, shop more styles inspired by her go-to heels that you can grab on Amazon.

Rsxses Suede Platform Heeled Sandal

Buy on Amazon $39

Jeossy 8801 Wedge Sandal

Buy on Amazon $40

Cushionaire Sisi Heeled Sandal

Buy on Amazon $40

The Drop Listilla Espadrille Wedge Sandal

Buy on Amazon $50

Naturalizer Lilly Ankle-Strap Platform Sandal

Buy on Amazon $110 $61